Carving meat might not be challenging to do, but have you tried carving it with a chef knife? How did it go? Was it easy to do? Did you notice any difference compared to carving it with an actual carving knife? Would you agree it is possible to carve it with a chef knife?
Check out here the best kitchen knives you can buy.
Carving with a chef knife is definitely possible. However, it might be harder due to the shape of the knife. This is especially the case with smaller chickens, as it is more delicate work and, therefore, harder with a bigger chef knife. Also, due to the chef knife’s shape, it tends to stick more compared with a carving knife, which is a less “tall” knife.
Yes, we all have been there, it’s that time of year, and there is a huge turkey on the table that needs to be carved. This year, your mother tasked you to carve the turkey. Your nervous, you look around the table only to find a chef knife. Probably you are thinking. It’s okay. A knife is a knife. As long it cuts, it will get the job done.
But you are used to carving with an actual carving knife. It cuts so quickly and so easily. You start to think maybe I should have said let someone else do it. But its too late now, you already agreed you would be the cutting master for tonight’s feast.
You start sweating and think, what if I fail to cut even pieces? What if the pieces look horrible, and because of me, this dinner is ruined? What if the dinner is ruined and everyone leaves and they all get mad at me and next year I am not invited anymore?
Okay, okay, I’ll stop.
The story is obviously made up, I am sure that nobody was ever in this kind of situation, but it does make you think, would you be able to carve with a chef knife? Naturally, your first thought would be, of course! But let’s find out if that is true, shall we?
The chef knife’s versatility
Chef knife is for everyday cooking, and in everyday cooking, versatility is key. If you’re an ordinary cook, you probably cook quick and easy meals most days of the week, and from time to time, bigger and more complex meals when you feel confident and or have the time.
Therefore, you probably don’t’ really need a full set of expert kitchen knives. A chef knife would do the job just fine. This handy, classically shaped knife will make all your basic food preparation tasks light, like chopping and slicing fresh ingredients.
A great chef’s knife can improve how you feel about cooking altogether. Carving with a chef knife can be done, but it will be messy, and if you are not skilled enough, you most likely will end up uneven sliced pieces.
Best used for:
- Cutting meat (no thin slices)
- Dicing vegetables
- Disjointing meat
- Chopping nuts
- Slicing herb
Should not be used for:
- Cleaving meat bones
- Slicing bread
- Carving dense meat
- Smaller delicate tasks, such as peeling and mincing.
Should you use a carving knife?
Yes! But only if you have one. If you had to, you could work in the kitchen with just one knife. Specific knives have been created to speed up time when preparing and serving meals — time that can be important in a professional kitchen.
However, as I previously mentioned if you’re skilled with a chef’s knife, you can easily and safely carve roasts with it. As long it’s nice and sharp, to get those paper-thin cuts would be not really a hard job. However, this would be difficult and time-consuming. The whole point of a carving knife is that they have a narrower belly.
This leads to less sliding friction against the roast, which in result gets you those smoother cuts. The long thin form of most carvings knives also permits you to get greater precision sectioning the meat, which significantly impacts the presentation of the meal and how consumers receive it. The more delicate blades also produce less drag on the meat, keeping it intact.
Best used for:
- Slicing thin cuts of meat, such as chicken, beef, venison and fish
- Preparing Vegetables
- Preparing fruit for salads
Should not be used for:
- Small delicate tasks, such as peeling and mincing.
- Cleaving meat bones
When to use which knife
In all honesty, I did not have a carving knife for a long time. We learned at the culinary school how to use one, and of course, we worked with it from time to time till we graduated. But back then, I was a newbie and had no sense of anything, so I kind of forgot why we would even use different types of knives if all of them were doing the same.
Many years later at some point, I received a knife set as a gift, and this was when I started using more often a carving knife. Before that, a chef knife was versatile enough for me to use it for almost all tasks. But as I mention this in practically all of my articles.
There is a difference between getting a job done and optimally performing a job. Even though I can carve a turkey with a chef knife, it does not mean I should. I am a true believer in using the right knife for the right task.
And have been ever since I started looking at the difference between knives and the results I get. So if you ask me if you own a set of knives, you should always try to use the right one.
What is the best knife for carving meat?
Various types of meat and the slices you can use all have their own unique qualities. Before choosing a carving or slicing knife, here are the following points you should consider:
- Will you be carving a bone?
- Do you require to cut thin, even slices?
- How thick is the cut of meat you are carving?
- How soft is the meat?
This short guide gives you an idea of what type of knife (with links to Amazon) is best for which occasion:
A scalloped edge lets cold and moist meat such as beef easily drop off the blade after slicing.
Similar to the scalloped edge, the flutes on this knife merged with a skinny blade makes it more comfortable to keep portions whole when slicing salmon and other fish. The slim blade decreases drag and allows for maneuverability around delicate fish bones.
Perfect for carving a big roast of turkey, boneless beef joint, or breast. It allows you to do long, even slices.
Similar to the Japanese sashimi knife design, which is traditionally used for delicately carving portions of fish. The European influence of a double-beveled knife makes it suitable for red meat, fowl, and fish.
Pointed-tip carving knife
The durable, firm blade makes cuts containing delicate connective tissue easy work, while the pointed tip is ideal for dividing meat from bone on joints of beef, lamb, and poultry.
Should I use an electric carving knife?
You can see this in a lot of homes and even in movies. The electric carving knife is purely for those who just want an easy fix. You would rarely find an Electric carving knife in a professional kitchen. Due to their sizes and serrated blades, they rip and tear through food, and it is almost impossible to perform delicate cuts.
If you are working around a bone, your best option is to use a handheld knife. A meat slicer is easy to use, especially for large pieces of boneless meat, it leaves less waste, and you will be able to get even slices with none of the disadvantages of an electric knife.